More Typical Very Old Car Experience

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by JW, Jan 23, 2004.

  1. JW

    Patrick Guest

    You may be right, it might be a Maytag Neptune and not Calypso. I'm
    continually using the wrong name.

    Unfortunately, my new Kenmore washer was returned after delivery and
    replaced by a new one. The computer had not been programmed properly
    and the function "add a garment" was missing.

    Btw, the Kenmore HE3T has 2 computers. One main CPU and a second one
    whose only purpose is to control the electric motor making the drum
    spins. That CPU gets so hot, it has a HUGE heat sink. Also,
    replacing the main CPU will cost you $400 for the part alone, before
    taxes and installation. That's not cheap in my book.

    P.S. Get a HE3T, it's a wonderful beast weighting ~ 320 pounds and
    has 4 shocks, 2 coil springs, 150 pounds of concrete and the drums
    spins at 72MPH (1200RPM X diameter of drum).
     
    Patrick, Jan 24, 2004
    #21
  2. JW

    Spanky Guest



    I agree. It's funny, my participation in this topic started with me taking
    exception to the author of the article that was skeptical of an older car
    that "ran like a top". I know that there are many fine older cars out there
    that are not a headache to keep in good repair.

    Then someone said, yes, but try that with a modern car. I think the modern
    ones are even better so I ended up arguing that. In the end, the Volvo's are
    nicer cars than the domestics, no matter what year you are talking.
     
    Spanky, Jan 24, 2004
    #22
  3. JW

    Patrick Guest

    I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure that the first few years of
    production of the S80 did NOT have air bags that adjust depending on
    any factor whatsoever.

    Like I said, I could be wrong, but I remember reading about it and
    finding out that BMW had it for years, but not Volvo.

    Older Volvos espoused the philosophy of the founders of Volvo.
     
    Patrick, Jan 24, 2004
    #23
  4. JW

    Patrick Guest

    James, I have more than 20 years of marketing/R&D experience behind
    me. Trust me, things are made cheaper. From house to dishwashers,
    building obsolence in a new product is a way of life nowadays. It
    doesn't pay to build a product the way it was made in the 50s, 60s and
    70s.

    Regarding the Kenmore Elite HE3T, you will be glad to know that it is
    NOT made in the USA, but in Germany. I forgot the name, but it is
    sold in Europe under another brand name. And though it only makes
    about 2-3 years it is available in the USA, it has been sold in Europe
    for the last 30+ years. Build quality is excellent, though slowly
    slipping.

    It is a far superior product to any non-commercial cloth washers sold
    in the USA. Front loading are resources effective and achieve a
    higher level of cleaning than top loading. Something like 1/4 to 1/5
    the electricity cost and 1/3 the water consumed, compared with top
    loading machine. I researched washers for a month before buying it.
     
    Patrick, Jan 24, 2004
    #24
  5. JW

    Spanky Guest

    Yes, you are wrong. The S80 had dual sensitivity airbags right from the
    first model year, 1999.
     
    Spanky, Jan 24, 2004
    #25
  6. JW

    James Sweet Guest

    Funny you should mention it, I've been in the market for a new front loading
    washer and a dryer, but I'm paranoid of getting some cheap piece of crap
    that'll fall apart. I'll remember that model and check it out.
     
    James Sweet, Jan 24, 2004
    #26
  7. JW

    Bill Stehlin Guest

    My sister has a v70, s80 and her post teens have their old 245s. The
    v70 and s80 are "really nice performers" when running well, but they
    spend an inordinately high amount of time in the shop, and the repairs
    are $$$. The 240s w/ 200K miles go in for routine maintenance and
    expenses are minimal. Any car that costs too much to keep running
    well and looking good will be retired. Functional obsolescence. As
    stated, a new $20K Accord will "outperform" a 7 year old $40K 850R.
    Add to the "outperform" a new car smell, better reliability and far
    lower maintenance costs and there is little incentive to keep the old
    car, certainly not for another 13 masochistic years.
    Maybe not 1984 (wiring harness, rust and fuel injection problems) but
    the idea that a Volvo from, say, 1992 will NOT last longer than the
    same priced car from 2004 with the same amount of maintenance and
    repairs (especially because of the extremely high costs of replacing
    expensive parts such as computers and integrated components which have
    been experiencing such a high failure rate that Volvo
    reliability/reputation has taken a serious hit ) is quite simply
    insane. Enough said!
     
    Bill Stehlin, Jan 24, 2004
    #27
  8. JW

    Spanky Guest

    Bill, the idea that the computers in modern cars are not reliable is in
    direct opposition to my own observation of 20 or 30 newer Volvos that are
    owned and driven by family, friends and acquaintances of mine on a daily
    basis. These cars span the last 10 years of production. If these computers
    were failing at a rate that was significant, how come none of the Volvo
    owners that I know are experiencing any computer failures?

    I'm not saying there are zero failures when the entire world fleet is
    considered, just that the rate is very low. Furthermore, I would be willing
    to bet that the majority of computer failures are caused by human error,
    i.e.. incorrect jump starting procedure, incorrect battery replacement
    procedure, incorrectly wired electrical "add-ons", etc. etc.

    There's no doubt that a modern multi-plexed wiring system is different from
    the type of wiring we are all familiar with and it does not lend itself to
    owner modifications. A typical luxury car with a conventional electrical
    system will have 3 miles of wire weighing hundreds of pounds and thousands
    of electrical connections. Multi-plexing reduces this by a dramatic amount.
    It's like having a specially designed automotive Ethernet network.
    Multiplexing means fewer wires, fewer connectors, and fewer terminals. This
    results in less materials to chafe, corrode. shake loose, etc. In addition,
    troubleshooting or diagnosis of a problem is easier although the diagnostic
    equipment is more complex. Less connections = less problems. Cars are
    getting better and easier to diagnose but you won't be able to track down an
    electrical problem with a free Saturday afternoon and a multi-meter. A
    specialized technician and sophisticated equipment will spot the problem in
    minutes.
     
    Spanky, Jan 24, 2004
    #28
  9. JW

    Per Hauge Guest

    Well I think Patrick is right. The following is qouted from Volvo VADIS:

    "1 stage deployment
    The front airbags had 1-stage deployment in model year 1999-2000 cars.
    When the SRS (supplemental restraint system) control module decides to
    deploy the airbags, deployment occurs at the same force.

    2 stage deployment
    The front airbags have 2-stage deployment in cars from model year 2001.
    When the SRS (supplemental restraint system) control module deploys the
    front airbags, both stages are deployed. By varying the time between the two
    deployments, softer airbag deployment is achieved in the event of a low
    speed collision"

    However The SRS/SIPS is operating with 2 collision levels, which is being
    used by the control module to evaluate whether to deploy only the seat belt
    retentioner or the airbags or both.

    In the year 2001 models SRS/SIPS is operating with 5 levels.

    Per Hauge
     
    Per Hauge, Jan 25, 2004
    #29
  10. JW

    Bill Stehlin Guest

    Spanky,
    My response was to poster saying that newer cars of same cost (in old
    dollars) w/ same maintenance expenditures would outlast older cars.
    One only has to look at the nearby post "Has anyone worn out an 850
    yet?" to see some of the problems and associated costs on the newer
    Volvos, and the end of run 850s were a lot better than the first few
    years of the V70. In fact JW (who was claiming new Volvos are better
    made and will outlast old ones) was complaining about the $$ problems
    he was having w/ a '96 850. Possibly the newer ones are as well made
    as the 240, but the added sophistication of the systems and expense of
    maintenance/parts IMHO will result in them being dumped long before 20
    years -- just way too much $$ to keep them going, unlike the older
    240.
     
    Bill Stehlin, Jan 25, 2004
    #30
  11. JW

    Spanky Guest

    No, I was correct all along. The section you are quoting from VADIS is
    mostly speaking of deploying the air bags at two different intensities
    depending upon the force of the collision. That was implemented in 2001
    models. Patrick and I were discussing the 2 collision level sensor
    (depending upon whether the occupant is belted or not). This 2 collision
    level sensor was deployed on the first S80's (1999 and up). In 2001 (in
    response to the criticisms that the bags were too sensitive) they upgraded
    the collision level sensor to operate with 5 levels.

    As you can see, airbag deployment is more sophisticated than many realize.
     
    Spanky, Jan 25, 2004
    #31
  12. JW

    Per Hauge Guest

    Well I guess I got confused about your disscusion om "sensitive airbags"
    In my opinion its the sensor system that operates with different levels of
    sensitivity, as I also wrote: 2 in 1999 and 5 from 2001. Airbags are
    sensitive to electrical signals, but I dont think this is the issue.
     
    Per Hauge, Jan 26, 2004
    #32
  13. JW

    myren Guest

    my `84 240dl is 197k old and i love her very much. thank you for
    dealing with my youthful abusiveness (curbs) and not abandoning me.

    considering doing silly things like going to Crazy Ray's and ripping a
    740T turbo setup out for some new life.

    should probably fix that master cylinder first though. :-]
     
    myren, Feb 1, 2004
    #33
  14. JW

    myren Guest

    that strikes me as a rather good reason to believe the first quote. how
    many people need 240 HP cars? they're not strong thinkers and decide
    they need to plunk down a huge chunk of change to drive 55 in the left
    lane. its always that asshole in the beemer. ;-] there's something to
    be said for not having ride control so advanced you have no idea how
    fast^H^H^H^Hslow you're going (talking on your cell phone).

    dont speak to me about performance when you drive a front wheel drive
    car (jest! jest! flamesuit on).

    unless its awd, which is aceptable. in another six years when awd comes
    with some sort of quattro/skyline/evo drive controller more or less
    standard, i can understand the performance line a lot better.

    i do see the "common" car becoming more performance aware, which is nice
    and cute. before you drove a sports car or other random gem you could
    get rediculous bolt on horsepower for. but the average car just wouldnt
    cut it. this is an interesting phenomenon i hadnt really put my finger
    on before.

    i am sincerely worried about the aftermarket world though. before the
    gems got made into gods: you knew they were good, so you kept building
    new aftermarket bolt ons. now every car and their mother begs for
    aftermarket but there's not enough people buying. who needs aftermarket
    when you've got 240 HP, right?

    myren
     
    myren, Feb 1, 2004
    #34
  15. JW

    myren Guest

    the other great joy about old cars is you can repair them yourself
    unlike a lot of modern cars. the comparitive maintence cost of DIY
    versus having to go somewhere is an order of magnitude. compound this
    with being able to junk yard the controller arm for my 84 240dl and
    there's no way i could afford a new car.
     
    myren, Feb 1, 2004
    #35
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.